The Jewish Left Before Israel: What Can Bundism Teach Us About Anti-Zionism?

Schedule

Wed, 18 Nov, 2026 at 07:00 pm

UTC+00:00
Location

The Bay Horse Inn, Totnes | Totnes, EN

Advertisement
Totnes Left Book Club presents...
The Jewish Left Before Israel: What Can Bundism Teach Us About Anti-Zionism?
The Jewish Labour Bund was a radical socialist movement founded in Eastern Europe in 1897. it developed a distinctive vision of Jewish liberation rooted in working-class solidarity, secularism, socialism and doikayt, meaning “hereness”: the principle that Jewish people should be able to live freely, with dignity and collective rights, wherever they call home, building their future through solidarity and political struggle rather than relying on a separate nation-state as the answer to antisemitism.
The Bund was founded in the same year as the First Zionist Congress in 1897, at a time when different visions of Jewish liberation were taking shape. While political Zionism sought a Jewish national home in Palestine, the Bund argued that Jewish freedom should be built where Jewish people already lived, through socialism, democratic rights, cultural autonomy and solidarity with other workers. It became a determined opponent of Zionism, rejecting the idea that Jewish emancipation depended on establishing a separate Jewish state.
Language was central to this difference. The Bund championed Yiddish, the everyday language of millions of Eastern European Jews, as a language of working-class organisation, literature, education and cultural life. While the Zionist movement increasingly promoted Hebrew as the language of Jewish national revival centred on Palestine, the Bund defended the possibility of a flourishing Jewish cultural life in the diaspora. For Bundists, Jewish culture did not have to be abandoned or assimilated, nor did it depend on being relocated to survive. It could flourish alongside other cultures as part of a broader struggle for social and political liberation.
For this meeting, we’ll be exploring the history and ideas of the Bund through the work of artist and writer Molly Crabapple, whose recent book Here Where We Live Is Our Country: The Story of the Jewish Bund has brought renewed attention to this important, and often overlooked, tradition of Jewish socialist and anti-Zionist thought.
You don’t need to read the book to take part. We'd particularly encourage people to watch or listen to Molly Crabapple’s interview on Democracy Now!, or listen to her conversation on the Alexei Sayle podcast. The links are below, along with one to a 1987 documentary on the subject. The book itself is there for anyone who wants to explore the subject further.
We’ll also be drawing on Benjamin Balthaser’s 2025 book Citizens of the Whole World: Anti-Zionism and the Cultures of the American Jewish Left, which traces the history of Jewish radicalism and internationalist socialism in the United States, from the 1930s to the present. Alongside this, the 2023 pamphlet published by the (UK based) Jewish Socialists’ Group: The Jewish Workers’ Bund: Past, Present and Future, which offers a valuable introduction to the movement’s history, its ideas and its continuing relevance to struggles against racism and fascism, and for social justice and equality.
These are histories with contemporary resonance. They invite us to consider the relationship between socialism, nationalism, identity and international solidarity, and to ask how people can pursue collective liberation without that necessarily taking the form of a nation-state. They also offer a way to explore the diversity of Jewish political traditions, and the longstanding presence of Jewish voices that have challenged Zionism from socialist, internationalist and other perspectives.
Our starting point is a commitment to human equality, opposition to racism and antisemitism, and solidarity across national, ethnic and religious boundaries. Jewish identity is not synonymous with Zionism, and Jewish people hold a range of views on Zionism and anti-Zionism. The Bund represents one important strand of Jewish political history, not a position that should be imposed on Jewish people today.
Criticism of Zionism or of the policies and actions of the Israeli state is not, in itself, hostility towards Jewish people. Equally, opposition to Zionism does not excuse antisemitism, collective blame or prejudice against Jews. We believe everyone deserves safety, dignity and the freedom to live without persecution.
Resources
📚 Molly Crabapple, Here Where We Live Is Our Country: The Story of the Jewish Bund
https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/here-where-we-live-is-our-country-9781526628893/
(Also available as an audiobook/Kindle)
🎥 Democracy Now! interview (14 May 2026): “Here Where We Live Is Our Country”: Molly Crabapple on Resurfacing the Jewish History of Anti-Zionism
https://www.democracynow.org/2026/5/14/the_bund_crabapple
🎧 The Alexei Sayle Podcast 4 July 2026: The Bund, the DSA and the F*cking Left (with Molly Crabapple)
https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-alexei-sayle-podcast/id1540500007?i=1000775417795
📖 Citizens of the Whole World: Anti-Zionism and the Cultures of the American Jewish Left (2025) by Benjamin Balthaser
https://www.versobooks.com/en-gb/products/2788-citizens-of-the-whole-world
📄 📄 The Jewish Socialists’ Group, The Jewish Workers’ Bund: Past, Present and Future (February 2023)
A free pamphlet bringing together historical accounts, personal testimonies and reflections on the continuing relevance of the Jewish Workers’ Bund, the Eastern European Jewish socialist movement founded in 1897. Featuring contributions from Bundists and later generations of Jewish socialists, it explores the Bund’s commitment to doikayt (“hereness”), minority rights, diaspora identity, resistance to fascism and the struggle for social justice and equality. It offers a useful introduction to the movement’s history and its relevance to contemporary debates.
Read or download: https://www.jewishsocialist.org.uk/news/item/the-jewish-workers-bund-pamphlet-news
🎬 Bund: The Hope & the Past (1987), directed by David Kedem
An hour-long documentary filmed in New York City and Israel in 1986, exploring the history of the Jewish Labour Bund from its origins in Tsarist Russia in the late 19th century through its growth as a major Jewish socialist movement in interwar Poland, its underground resistance during the Nazi occupation, and its postwar history. Featuring interviews with Bundist activists and Israeli historians, the film examines the movement’s commitment to socialism, Jewish cultural identity and collective life in the diaspora, as well as its declining membership by the 1980s.
Watch for free on Vimeo:
https://vimeo.com/1039972153
Advertisement

Where is it happening?

The Bay Horse Inn, Totnes, United Kingdom

Event Location & Nearby Stays:

Know what’s Happening Next — before everyone else does.
Totnes Left
Host or PublisherTotnes Left

Ask AI if this event suits you