M**der Mystery Dinner Theater
Schedule
Sun, 18 Jan, 2026 at 05:00 pm to Mon, 19 Jan, 2026 at 07:30 pm
UTC-05:00Location
200 W 44th St | New York, NY
Presented by Wanderlustory Events x The M**der Mystery Company
About this Event
What to Expect:
A live interactive performance full of suspects, secrets, and surprise twists
You’ll be assigned a character or role when you arrive — don’t worry, it’s optional but so fun!
A classic 1920s speakeasy setting. Costumes are encouraged (feathers, suspenders, pearls, etc.)
And of course… a M**der to solve
Tickets start at $105 per person — BUT if you join my group, you’ll save up to 30% off your ticket!
Limited spots available — once we’re full, the mystery begins without you. We will meet on January 18, 2026 and March 8, 2026 (my birthday!)
Join me for an unforgettable night of food, M**der and mystery.
What’s Included:
Three-Course Dinner at Carmine’s – classic family-style Italian favorites in an iconic Times Square setting
Live Theatrical Performance – professionally acted M**der mystery show by The M**der Mystery Company
Character Role Assignment – optional roles for guests who want to participate in the investigation
Interactive Clues & Mystery Solving – gather hints, interrogate suspects, and work as a team
Costumes Encouraged – throw on your flapper dresses, suspenders, fedoras, and pearls (but it’s not required!)
Let’s sip, solve, and slay the case in style.
Perfect for:
- Date nights that break the dinner-and-a-movie cycle
- Girls night out with drama and pasta
- Birthday or celebration events with flair
- Solo adventurers who want something fun + new
- Anyone obsessed with Clue, Knives Out, or M**der podcasts
Where is it happening?
200 W 44th St, 200 West 44th Street, New York, United StatesEvent Location & Nearby Stays:
USD 113.89 to USD 124.56
