The animal and the thinker. A conversation with Professor John Duncan

In our divided times, there has never been more need to know ourselves. The big questions of our lives bring fierce debates. Right and wrong. Freedom and responsibility. Women and men. Democracy and justice. Ambition and fulfilment. Where does the truth lie in a mind that produces the many sides and needs of humanity?

In The Animal and the Thinker, the neuroscientist John Duncan lays out the principles, strengths and weaknesses of two sides of ourselves. One side follows the principles of instinctive animal behaviour. Often our animal side has been seen as a disruptive Mr Hyde, to be overcome by human reason, but Duncan shows this is far from the truth. Our own animal side is elaborate, sophisticated, conflicted but essential - without it, our life would have no meaning. On the other side is our rational brain. It generates an infinite world of new ideas, essential for adapting our lives to complex changing circumstances. Often, however, its need for focus generates sterile social beliefs and destructive culture wars. Our rational side is brilliant, but often, it is wrong.

For thousands of years, writers, thinkers and philosophers have seen human life as a war between Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Duncan argues that there is no war. To bring humanity and reality to the great, conflicted questions of our lives, we need the dance between these two essential sides of ourselves.

Know what’s Happening Next — before everyone else does.

Get App

Host or Publisher Murray Edwards College