Serial Killer Speakeasy - Evansville, IN

Schedule

Fri, 26 Jun, 2026 at 06:00 pm

UTC-06:00

Location

Old Post Office Event Center | Evansville, IN

Advertisement
⭐  Serial Killer Speakeasy is a chilling immersive experience where four infamous stories unfold live on stage. It’s like stepping inside your favorite true-crime podcast—but with premium cocktails, an ominous atmosphere, and a killer twist. 🔪 Highlights ✨ A True-Crime Descent: Step into the shadows as the terrifying stories of Bundy, Dahmer, Gacy, and Gein are brought to life before your eyes. 🍸 Sip the Story: Enjoy a curated tasting menu of 4 delicious, themed cocktails paired perfectly with each tale 🎭 Immersive Theater: Lose yourself in gripping, atmospheric live performances told through the twisted perspectives of the killers themselves. 🚨 For the Morbidly Curious: A meticulously crafted, 90-minute evening designed specifically for those irresistibly drawn to the darker side of history. 📂 The Setlist: 4 Killers, 4 Drinks Case File 1: Ted Bundy – Paired with the Friendly Stranger Case File 2: Jeffrey Dahmer – Paired with the Apartment Two One Three Case File 3: John Wayne Gacy – Paired with the Killer Clowns Case File 4: Ed Gein – Paired with the Gein’s Cauldron General Info 📅 Date and time: Choose in the ticket selector ⏳ Duration: 1 hour and 30 minutes 📍 Location: Old Post Office Event Center 👤 Age requirement: guests have to be 21+ with valid ID ♿ Accessibility: The venue is ADA compliant ❓Please consult the FAQs of this experience here 🍹 Mocktails available upon request Description Brought to you by Midnight Creative, step inside the shadows and immerse yourself in the dark, twisted histories of America's most notorious serial killers. This exclusive touring event transforms Old Post Office Event Center into a gripping true-crime sanctuary. As you sip on expertly crafted spirits or bespoke mocktails, our mixologists and theatrical storytellers will plunge you deep into the minds and motives of Bundy, Dahmer, Gacy, and Gein. It is an unforgettable blend of tension, dark history, and theatrical intrigue. Tickets sell out fast—don’t miss your chance to unravel these chilling accounts, one sip at a time! Produced by Midnight Creative , creators of the highly reviewed International touring Edgar Allan Poe Speakeasy,
Advertisement

Where is it happening?

Old Post Office Event Center, 100 NW 2nd St, Evansville, United States

Event Location & Nearby Stays:

Icon
Know what’s Happening Next — before everyone else does.
Feverup Events

Host or Publisher Feverup Events

Ask AI if this event suits you:

Discover More Events in Evansville

Summer Bash
Sat, 27 Jun at 12:00 pm Summer Bash

1212 S Garvin St, Evansville, IN 47713-2110, United States

Christian Singles Night
Sat, 27 Jun at 06:30 pm Christian Singles Night

Warehouse 410

FOOD-DRINKS
Ghost Hunt The Uss LST-325
Sat, 27 Jun at 07:00 pm Ghost Hunt The Uss LST-325

USS LST-325 War Ship, 610 NW Riverside Dr, Evansville, IN 47708, USA

SolemnlySwear,  PortraitofBetrayal, LightsOut, Kaptured @ Ray Leo's
Sat, 27 Jun at 07:00 pm SolemnlySwear, PortraitofBetrayal, LightsOut, Kaptured @ Ray Leo's

Ray Leo's at Lamasco

Shades of HUNKS at Xcess Night Club (Evansville, IN) 06\/27\/26
Sat, 27 Jun at 08:00 pm Shades of HUNKS at Xcess Night Club (Evansville, IN) 06/27/26

Xcess Night Club

ENTERTAINMENT PERFORMANCES
Fuzzzy Talks Live Comedy Podcast [Vendors Welcome]
Thu, 26 Feb at 07:00 pm Fuzzzy Talks Live Comedy Podcast [Vendors Welcome]

Evansville

COMEDY
Fun City Scavenger Hunt in Evansville by Operation City Quest
Fri, 27 Mar at 09:00 am Fun City Scavenger Hunt in Evansville by Operation City Quest

Evansville Civic Center Complex

CONTESTS
Nerd Nite
Thu, 30 Apr Nerd Nite

22 NW 6th Street , Evansville, IN, United States, Indiana 47708

SCIENCE-FAIR
Ritmos Latinos: Bachata group class.  $5 Cash in person
Wed, 06 May at 07:00 pm Ritmos Latinos: Bachata group class. $5 Cash in person

Main Street Food and Beverage

WORKSHOPS FOOD-DRINKS
Powerful Voices Open Mic Show - Live Music, Comedy, Poetry+ More!
Thu, 14 May at 07:00 pm Powerful Voices Open Mic Show - Live Music, Comedy, Poetry+ More!

Evansville

ART OPEN-MIC
Customer Appreciation Days
Fri, 15 May at 10:00 am Customer Appreciation Days

Thyme in the Kitchen

Summer Open House\u2600\ufe0f
Fri, 15 May at 10:00 am Summer Open House☀️

7212 Olmstead Road, Evansville, IN, United States, Indiana 47715

SHOPPING
Spring Yard Sale!
Sat, 16 May at 08:00 am Spring Yard Sale!

The Salvation Army of Evansville, Serving Warrick& Vanderburgh Counties

NONPROFIT CHARITIES
2026 RiverCity Fit Expo & NPC Indiana Muscle
Sat, 16 May at 08:30 am 2026 RiverCity Fit Expo & NPC Indiana Muscle

Old National Events Plaza

BUSINESS EXHIBITIONS
Anniversary Party
Sat, 16 May at 11:00 am Anniversary Party

4700 E Morgan Ave, Evansville, IN, United States, Indiana 47715

Bleachers Advanced Listening Party - Space Monkey Records
Sat, 16 May at 04:00 pm Bleachers Advanced Listening Party - Space Monkey Records

1201 E Riverside Dr, Evansville, IN, United States, Indiana 47714

Diamonds & Pearls 8th Annual Mother Daughter Dance
Sat, 16 May at 06:00 pm Diamonds & Pearls 8th Annual Mother Daughter Dance

Greater St. James CREC Center

Hadi Shriners Cinco de Mayo Bingo
Sat, 16 May at 06:00 pm Hadi Shriners Cinco de Mayo Bingo

6 Walnut St, Evansville, IN, United States, Indiana 47708

BINGO
The PITS! It's Geno's "Going Away" Mid May Melee @ BOKEH!!!
Sat, 16 May at 08:00 pm The PITS! It's Geno's "Going Away" Mid May Melee @ BOKEH!!!

Bokeh Lounge

ENTERTAINMENT PARTIES
Scarecrow Returns to Lyle\u2019s
Sat, 16 May at 08:00 pm Scarecrow Returns to Lyle’s

Lyle’s Sports Bar

SPORTS

What's Happening Next in Evansville?

Discover Evansville Events