Criminally Stupid: The Search For the World’s Dumbest Criminal
Schedule
Sat Apr 25 2026 at 09:00 pm to 10:00 pm
UTC-04:00Location
The Shillelagh Tavern | Queens, NY
About this Event
Criminally Stupid: The Search For the World’s Dumbest Criminal
A Live Show with Crawlspace & Another F*cking Horror Podcast
What happens when two true crime podcasts come together for one night only? They talk about really dumb criminals, of course!
For the first time ever, Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna - the team behind such beloved podcasts as Missing & Crawlspace - and Monique Sanchez and Amy Traydon, the BFFs from the paranormal, true crime, comedy hit, Another F*cking Horror Podcast, are sharing a stage and bringing their A-game to celebrate and humiliate the world’s most criminally challenged.
Each host will take the mic to present their case: a true story of a criminal so spectacularly and breathtakingly stupid that it will prove that truth is indeed stranger than fiction.
Evidence will be presented. Arguments will be made. Dignity will be lost.
Once our hosts have rested their cases, that’s when the real fun begins. At the end of the night, you, the audience, will vote on who will be crowned The World’s Dumbest Criminal.
Part true crime, part comedy show, all laughs, Criminally Stupid is a night you won't want to miss - unless you're the kind of person who leaves a 5-star review on the ski mask you used to rob a bank - which, 1- that has absolutely happened and 2 - in that case, you might want to sit this one out.
Saturday, April 25th at 9PM Shillelagh Tavern - 47-22 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11103
Show starts at 9PM, but the night doesn't stop there - stick around and keep the party going with Karaoke at 11PM. Come for the crimes. Stay for the singing. We're not judging. Well, actually, we are. That's kind of the whole point.
This is a 21+ event. Valid ID required.
Where is it happening?
The Shillelagh Tavern, 47-22 30th Avenue, Queens, United StatesEvent Location & Nearby Stays:
USD 25.31



















