Candlelight Theatre | 2023-2024 Season Tickets

Each season features plays within the 23rd President’s historic mansion, which provides an authentic backdrop.

Creative Director Donna Wing, Resident Playwright James Trofatter and a dedicated company of seasoned actors perform a combination of mysteries, comedies and thrilling historically-inspired tales.

• In the fall, an interactive M**der mystery puts you in the middle of the investigation of a M**der at Garrison Manor.
• Candlelight Theatre’s holiday performance is ‘Tis the Season. Join us to sip hot cider, enjoy carolers, and meet holiday figures from tradition and folklore, as well as jolly new friends.
• Hoosier (H)Arts, a celebration of Valentine’s Day, Black History Month and Indiana poets, returns in February.
• Spring productions follow a salon theatre format, using the mansion to share intimate one-act mysteries and comedies.

Read more about season ticket package options and 2023-2024 productions below.

• One ticket to all four Candlelight Theatre 2023-2024 productions

• Price includes membership to the Presidential Site

• Already a member? Enjoy a huge price savings!

• Two tickets to all four Candlelight Theatre 2023-2024 productions

• Includes membership to the Presidential Site for one individual

• One ticket to three of Candlelight Theatre's 2022-2023 productions

• Includes membership to the Presidential Site for one individual

• Already a member? Enjoy a huge price savings!

• Two tickets to three of Candlelight Theatre's 2022-2023 productions

• Includes membership to the Presidential Site for one individual

We will begin the season with M**der at the Manor, an interactive M**der mystery that puts you in the middle of the investigation of a M**der at Garrison Manor. Will your team be the first to solve the crime?

M**der at the Manor: October 13, 14, 20, 21, 28, 29 2023.

Candlelight Theatre’s holiday performance is ‘Tis the Season by resident playwright, James Trofatter. Join us to sip hot cider, enjoy carolers, and meet holiday figures from tradition and folklore, as well as jolly new friends.

‘Tis the Season: December 15, 16 & 17, 2023

Hoosier (H)Arts, a celebration of Valentine’s Day, Black History Month and Indiana poets, returns in February, 2024. This exclusive one-evening event features hors d’oeuvres followed by readings by some of Indiana’s best loved poets.

Hoosier (H)Arts: February 10, 2024.

Murders, Mystery, and Mirth is Candlelight Theatre’s spring signature performance. Three mystery plays will be presented salon-style in three different rooms of the mansion.

Murders, Mystery, and Mirth: April 19, 20, 26, 27,28 May 3 & 4, 2024.

Host or Publisher Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site